Edgar’s Bakery President’s Choice Panini

I am at it again with my grill press. This is the other sandwich that I love from Edgar’s Bakery in Birmingham. It is called the President’s Choice “Roast beef and melted mozzarella cheese with Peter Luger steak sauce on toasted multi grain bread.”  I am not sure why they call it the President’s Choice – maybe the President of Edgar’s likes it? Who knows?  It is a great sandwich whatever you call it.

I couldn’t find any Peter Luger steak sauce in town, so I went with Shula’s steak sauce.  I thought it was a good substitute since we have a Shula’s here in town.  We both really enjoyed the at home version of the sandwich.  We had a good time experimenting with Panini Month!

President’s Choice
(Printable Recipe)

2 slices Pepperidge Farms Soft Sourdough bread
2 slices mozzarella cheese
5 slices deli roast beef
2-3 tps Shula’s Steak Sauce
butter

Spread butter on one side of each piece of bread. Put one piece of mozzarella cheese each non-buttered side of bread. Top one side with roast beef and steak sauce. Place the remaining slice of bread butter side up ontop of meat. Place butter-side down in heated grill pan. (I used a grill press to press the sandwich down in the pan) Flip and grill until golden brown.