A Slice of Elvis – Peanut Butter Banana Pudding Pie

Peanut Butter Banana Pudding Pie

I use to love banana pudding when I was a kid – more specifically, I loved my Mom’s banana pudding.  I can remember waiting at the table with my little brother waiting for Mom to finish making the banana pudding. We loved to eat it warm.  We also preferred more Nilla wafers than bananas – turns out we just really liked warm vanilla pudding and Nilla wafers!  We would all fight over it!

I recently saw Southern Living’s recipe for banana pudding made with Nutter Butters.  It caught my eye because I love Nutter Butters. Seriously, I can’t buy them because I will eat the whole bag by myself and I don’t even eat sweets. 

Since it was a holiday and all, I decided to combine the two recipes into a pie.  I did a Nutter Butter crust and my childhood banana pudding.  I topped the pie with whipped cream because that is what I like.  My Mom would make meringe – Chicken Legs prefers meringe, but he wasn’t the cook. 🙂  The pie was great and I will be using this crust for another dessert – probably a cheesecake!

Peanut Butter Banana Pudding Pie
Peanut Butter Banana Pudding Pie

A Slice of Elvis – Peanut Butter Banana Pudding Pie
(Printable Recipe)

24 Nutter Butter cookies, finely crushed
⅓ cup butter, melted

2 bananas, sliced
1 box cook and serve vanilla pudding
3 cups milk

1 cup heavy whipping cream
¼ cup powdered sugar
1 tsp vanilla

Combine cookie crumbs and butter.  Pour into 9-inch pie plate and press in the bottom and up the sides of the dish.  Place sliced bananas on top of crust.  Set aside.

Cook pudding according to directions on the box.  Pour over bananas in crust.  Cover with plastic wrap to prevent skin forming (press plastic wrap directly on the pudding).  Refrigerate until set.

Before serving, mix together whipping cream, powdered sugar and vanilla.  Whip until it holds soft peaks.  Spread over pudding and serve!

Pin It!

post signature



You Might Also Like

See All Pie

Coconut Key Lime Pie

No-Bake Coconut Key Lime Pie Recipe – this heavenly dessert combines tangy Key lime juice with creamy coconut for a…

Dutch Apple Pie

Dutch Apple Pie Recipe – layers of tender, cinnamon-kissed apple slices tucked beneath a golden-brown, buttery crumble crust.

Sweet Potato Pie

Sweet Potato Pie Recipe – Silky-smooth filling made from the finest sweet potatoes, perfectly spiced and nestled in a flaky,…

No Bake Coconut Cream Pie

Easy No Bake Coconut Cream Pie Recipe – This is our favorite coconut pie recipe! SO easy and bursting with coconut…


  1. Hmmm,that crust sounds retty good. A nice change from nilla wafers or a graham cracker crust.

  2. I just love the ratio of whipped topping to pie. 1:1 in my book is always the way to go! Looks great=)

  3. Oooo chocolate cream pie + nutterbutter crust !! I hope to see that posted on your blog in the future 🙂

  4. i ADORE banana pudding. in fact, i rarely make it because i know i will eat it ALL 🙂 i've never had it with a nutterbutter crust though–i can't wait to use that for something!

  5. Katherine – The crust was great. It held up just like my usual graham cracker crusts. I plan on using it again soon. I'm thinking chocolate cream pie and nutter butter crust……

  6. Nutterbutter crust…now that's something new to me! How did the crust hold up? Was it just like using an oreo crust (same texture I mean) ?

  7. Funny, I luv nutter butters and really don't like the bananas in banana pudding.

    Thanks for sharing.

Leave a Comment