Butterfinger Pie {No Bake}

I've had this recipe for ages, but I haven't made it in a really long time. Chicken Legs was talking about it the other day, so I decided to make it for him. This is super easy and doesn't require any baking! That is a huge plus in this heat!

This pie only has 4 ingredients. I used a pre-made graham cracker crust, and this came together in minutes. The hardest part of this recipe was waiting for the pie to set up! It was pure torture! The pie is so light and creamy; that makes it SO easy to eat! 

Butterfinger Pie
serves 6-8
(Printable Recipe)

  • 1 graham cracker pie crust
  • 8 oz cream cheese, softened
  • 12oz cool whip, thawed
  • 7 (2.1 oz) Butterfinger candy bars, crushed

Combine softened cream cheese, cool whip and 6 crushed Butterfingers. Spoon into prepared graham cracker crust. Top with remaining crushed Butterfinger. Chill at least 4 hours.

Pin It!

  post signature



  1. OMG! Your pie caught my attention this morning and I can't wait to make it! I love easy recipes like this.

  2. Simply delicious! What a way to start the day. Can't wait to try this one out.

    Have a great weekend.

    Wishes for tasty dishes,
    Linda @ Tumbleweed Contessa

  3. I need this in my life. Obsessed with Butterfingers!

  4. Thinking of doing this with Reese's cups! Should be same formula, right? Thanks!

  5. Ray - I would think so. I bet it will be AMAZING with Reese's cups!

  6. This looks so yummy and it perfect for the summer! I try not to run the over in the summer, so I'm definitely pinning this for the future :-)

  7. This looks so good, can't wait to try it!

  8. Butterfinger was my favorite candy bar, then I developed an allergy to peanuts. Man this looks so good.

  9. Couldn't wait to try this. Bought the ingredients. Just got ready to make this. I only bought 2 candy bars. I hadn't looked at how much it needed, but thought surely 2 would be plenty. Wow, I was so shocked that this uses so much candy! Sad face insereted here!

  10. My generic cool whip is 8 oz. I didn't even look when I bought it. Does real cool whip come in 12 oz? Or did you use 1 1/2? Thanks for info!

  11. Ray - there is a 12oz container of cool whip.

  12. Thanks, Steph! I did 2/3 of the recipe AND made with the Reese's cups. It turned out great! Had to take baby steps to make it the full four hour waiting period, ugh.

    Thank you :)

    p.s. Next time I won't be cheap and will buy the Cool Whip brand...

  13. I've been making this pie for years, it's so easy. You are right, the hardest part is waiting for it to set up!

  14. Does this set up like a cheesecake?

    1. LVZell - it does set up after being refrigerated.

  15. When you say "chill" do you mean put in the refrigerator or the freezer? I know that sounds silly! Cannot wait to try this!

  16. can this pie be frozen? I will be traveling on Thursday and last year when I made it and traveled with it, it got melty. So I thought I may freeze Wednesday so when I travel Thursday it wont happen again.

  17. jenmcnatt3...I was wondering the same thing. Did you try freezing? I'm curious how it turned out.

  18. I'm sure this is delicious !It has 2 of the same ingredients as Snickers Dip just substituting the candy :) Gonna try this real soon !!!!


Back to Top