Party Roast Beef Sandwiches {Football Friday}

Party Roast Beef Sandwiches – CRAZY good! We are totally addicted to these sandwiches!! Hawaiian rolls, roast beef, white American cheese, topped with butter, brown sugar, horseradish sauce, Worcestershire sauce, and poppy seeds. These things go fast! I always double the recipe. They are also good reheated!

Party Roast Beef Sandwiches - CRAZY good! We are totally addicted to these sandwiches!! Hawaiian rolls, roast beef, white american cheese, topped with butter, brown sugar, horseradish sauce, worcestershire sauce and poppy seeds. These things go fast! I always double the recipe. They are also good reheated!

Remember this recipe.

Pin this recipe to your favorite board now to remember it later!

Pin This Recipe

New favorite alert! These Party Roast Beef Sandwiches are AMAZING! I absolutely love every single thing about these sandwiches! I love a good roast beef sandwich and these roast beef sandwiches are THE BEST. The meat, melty cheese and the sweet and savory sauce on top – perfection!

The key to these sandwiches is using white American cheese. It melts perfectly. You just can’t get other cheeses to melt like American cheese. The sauce has a little kick from some creamy horseradish. SO good.

These are perfect for a party. They also reheat beautifully. We had these for lunch two days in a row. I wrapped the leftovers in foil and reheated them for a few minutes in the oven. Just as good as the first time we ate them. I LOVE these sandwiches. Make them for a quick lunch, dinner or tailgate! You won’t regret it!

Party Roast Beef Sandwiches - CRAZY good! We are totally addicted to these sandwiches!! Hawaiian rolls, roast beef, white american cheese, topped with butter, brown sugar, horseradish sauce, worcestershire sauce and poppy seeds. These things go fast! I always double the recipe. They are also good reheated!
roast beef sandwiches on a plate

Party Roast Beef Sandwiches

Yield: 12 sandwiches
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 20 minutes
Total Time 30 minutes
Party Roast Beef Sandwiches – CRAZY good! We are totally addicted to these sandwiches!! Hawaiian rolls, roast beef, white American cheese, topped with butter, brown sugar, horseradish sauce, Worcestershire sauce, and poppy seeds. These things go fast! I always double the recipe. They are also good reheated!

Ingredients:

  • 1 (12-ct) package King's Hawaiian Rolls
  • ¾ lb thinly sliced deli roast beef
  • 3 Tbsp creamy horseradish sauce, divided
  • 8 slices white American cheese
  • 6 Tbsp butter
  • 2 Tbsp brown sugar
  • 1 Tbsp Worcestershire sauce
  • 1 Tbsp poppy seeds

Instructions:

  • Preheat oven to 350ºF.
  • Split each dinner roll. Spread a small amount of creamy horseradish sauce on the bottom of each roll. Make a sandwich of the roast beef and cheese and the dinner rolls. Arrange the sandwiches in a 9×13 pan.
  • In a small sauce pan combine butter, brown sugar, 1 Tbps horseradish sauce, Worcestershire and poppy seeds. Bring to a boil and pour over sandwiches.
  • Bake for 20-30 minutes, or until the tops are brown and crispy.

Steph

Remember this recipe.

Pin this recipe to your favorite board now to remember it later!

Pin This Recipe
Party Roast Beef Sandwiches - CRAZY good! We are totally addicted to these sandwiches!! Hawaiian rolls, roast beef, white american cheese, topped with butter, brown sugar, horseradish sauce, worcestershire sauce and poppy seeds. These things go fast! I always double the recipe. They are also good reheated!
Party Roast Beef Sandwiches - CRAZY good! We are totally addicted to these sandwiches!! Hawaiian rolls, roast beef, white american cheese, topped with butter, brown sugar, horseradish sauce, worcestershire sauce and poppy seeds. These things go fast! I always double the recipe. They are also good reheated!
Party Roast Beef Sandwiches - CRAZY good! We are totally addicted to these sandwiches!! Hawaiian rolls, roast beef, white american cheese, topped with butter, brown sugar, horseradish sauce, worcestershire sauce and poppy seeds. These things go fast! I always double the recipe. They are also good reheated!
Party Roast Beef Sandwiches - CRAZY good! We are totally addicted to these sandwiches!! Hawaiian rolls, roast beef, white american cheese, topped with butter, brown sugar, horseradish sauce, worcestershire sauce and poppy seeds. These things go fast! I always double the recipe. They are also good reheated!

Categories:

Tags:

You Might Also Like

See All Sandwiches

Tortilla Wrap Recipes

13 irresistible Tortilla Wraps and Pinwheel recipes! These versatile recipes are perfect for quick lunches, appetizers, or anytime cravings strike.…

BBQ Chicken Sliders

BBQ Chicken Sliders Recipe – Hawaiian rolls stuffed with tender chicken, crispy bacon, French fried onions, tangy BBQ sauce, and gooey…

Comments

  1. I’ve made these several times…. With roast beef but I just had pot roast last week. Ham should be just as good, right?

  2. Hi!!

    Do you think this recipe would still taste good without the sauce mixture poured on top?? We have a picky eater when it comes to texture so the “sogginess” would be an issue (even though I know to most it would be the best part). Thanks!

  3. Im making these today for Saturday football. I m making to the recipe because it sounds so great! Im using steak sums,deli was out of roast beef (imagine that) I love beef onion and horseradish together. Maybe I’ll sneak some onion in there. Always a picky person in the crowd. 😉

  4. This is about the 10th time I have made these. I make them exactly like the recipe calls. Perfection! My boys ask for this for their birthday dinner. I have made it with big crowds. Today is my son’s birthday, I actually rest of the beef myself yesterday. Thank you so much for such a delicious recipe! The part I love about it is the caramelizing crispiness that happens at the bottom of the roll. Devine!!!!!!!!!!!!

  5. I’m making these this weekend to take while we’re entertaining friends on the boat. I’ll be preparing it in our camper and camper ovens aren’t the best. They are small and only heat from the bottom. I bought a little 12v lunch box that I can keep them warm in. Do you have any suggestions on how to prepare them not using the oven?

  6. Absolutely delicious! I did change a few things however. I got the Hawaiian sweet rolls, but the savory butter ones instead. I also used boars head horseradish cheddar cheese and no additional horseradish sauce. I also added crispy fried onions on the sandwiches as well. Highly recommend!

  7. I just made these to take to the beach for 4th of July and had to sample one beforehand. OMG! So amazing! I had to do them in my air fryer on the bake setting because my kitchen is gutted. It took 6 minutes at 360 degrees and they were perfect.

  8. So once the sauce mixture boils, you pour it over the bun right away? Seems like it would destroy the bun. Or do you let it cool off for a few minutes?

    1. Don’t let the sauce boil too long. Cook it just until it starts to boil. You are just dissolving the sugar. The rolls should be fine, but you can certainly let the glaze cool a bit.

  9. I really loved these sandwiches. I didn’t use horseradish. My wife thought it was too sweet with the brown sugar and sweet rolls.

  10. These have been a hit everywhere I’ve taken them! I’ve made them at the beach, on a girls mtn. trip, family get together at Christmas & tonight we are having them at an election party! I am a fan of Boar’s Deluxe (low sodium), I just didn’t like them as much with store brand meats.

    1. Jenny Gerding–I too like these and they are super easy….I am from the Ohio Gerdings…are you too?

      Ruth Gerding

  11. This recipe is great! Easy to make and sooooo delicious!! I used Kroger deli roast beef and was great!! Will definitely make again! 👍😉

  12. I would love to try these, they look so good! But I'm Canadian and we can't get Hawaiian rolls or American cheese here. I'm sure I can find a substitute for the rolls but the cheese will be more difficult. Perhaps just a mix of Cheddar and Mozzarella?

    1. These are sooo good and easy! I use Kretchier or Hillshire farm roast beef – not a fan of Boer’s Head. BTY – you have the best recipes!

    1. They do….on purpose! And they’re delicious! I’ve made several versions of this sandwich, the Hawaiian rolls smothered in butter, then popped into the oven for a few minutes create a fantastic, very soft…some would call them a bit soggy, sandwich. They’re supposed to be that way. And no, they’re not for those that are constantly counting every calorie, but you can count calories another day, this is a splurge!

    1. You can bake them, cover and then refrigerate them. I would cover them with foil and just reheat them in the oven when you are ready to serve them.

  13. Made these sandwiches … so good! The only change to the recipe is that I mixed the horseradish cream with the butter, brown sugar, and Worcestershire sauce. I think that this recipe should be in your "Crack" recipe section because it is so "of-the-hook" good.

  14. I make something like this using leftover roast I cooked in the crock pot. They are delicious so I know these must be as well.

Leave a Comment

Recipe Rating