Butter Crunch Greek Yogurt Ice Cream

Butter Crunch Greek Yogurt Ice Cream

This is our favorite ice cream, so far, this summer. It was really creamy and had a nice tanginess from the Greek yogurt.  But, it was the Butterfingers that put this over the top! 

The inspiration for this ice cream came from a half-gallon of Blue Bell Ice Cream that we ate earlier this year.  It was SO good!  I could not control myself with it in the freezer. I vowed to never buy it again! 🙂 

I like to think that this homemade version is healthy since it is made with Greek yogurt.  Greek yogurt is fat-free and full of protien.  See?  Yeah, I’m not buying it either, but I am really enjoying this ice cream.  It goes perfectly with the Butterfinger Cookies from yesterday.

Butter Crunch Greek Yogurt Ice Cream

Butter Crunch Greek Yogurt Ice Cream
adapted from bonappetit.com
(Printable Recipe)

  • 1 cup heavy whipping cream
  • 1 cup whole milk
  • ¾ cup sugar, divided
  • 3 large egg yolks
  • 1 cup whole-milk Greek-style yogurt
  • Pinch of salt
  • 2 (3.7oz) King Size Butterfingers, crushed
  • Ice cream maker

Combine 1 cup heavy whipping cream, 1 cup whole milk, and ½ cup sugar in heavy medium saucepan. Bring mixture to simmer, stirring until sugar dissolves. Whisk 3 large egg yolks and remaining ¼ cup sugar in large heatproof bowl until blended. Gradually add hot cream mixture to yolk mixture and whisk until blended. Return mixture to saucepan and stir over medium-low heat until custard thickens slightly and coats back of spoon when finger is drawn across and instant-read thermometer inserted into mixture registers 170°F, about 3 minutes (do not boil). Pour custard into medium bowl. Place bowl with custard in larger bowl filled halfway with ice and water. Whisk occasionally until custard is almost cool to touch, about 5 minutes. Remove bowl with custard from ice water. Whisk yogurt and pinch of salt into custard. Refrigerate custard until well chilled.

Transfer custard to ice cream maker and process according to manufacturer’s instructions. Transfer yogurt ice cream to freezer container. Cover and freeze until ice cream is firm. Once firm, stir in crushed Butterfingers. (I find it is easier to cruch Butterfingers when they are frozen)

Pin It!

post signature




You Might Also Like

See All Blog

Rotel Recipes

Rotel Recipes – 15 of our family’s favorite recipes made with a can of rotel diced tomatoes and green chiles.…

Creole Cornbread

Creole Cornbread Recipe – homemade cornbread loaded with jalapeños, smoked sausage, cajun seasoning, dirty rice, and cheese. Super simple to…

Meow Monday

Meow Monday – pictures of cute cats to start the week. Come see what Felix, Mack, and Mango have been…


  1. LOL, it's healthier! 🙂 You're on a serious ice cream kick….I like it.

    I really, really enjoy ice creams made from sour cream and buttermilk, but I haven't tried Greek yogurt yet. I need to.

  2. Mmm, I wonder if I could fool our friend who likes healthy things and really hates yogurt but loves Butterfingers? Sounds de-lish to me!

  3. Mmmm, that does look divine. I would have never thought of using yogurt in ice cream, but Greek yogurt is in it's own class! And the butterfingers! Yesss!

  4. Perfect pairing! Now to get Butterfinger bars and hide them until I get the chance to make these!

  5. You are killing me with these Butterfinger recipes. Love the greek yogurt in this ice cream. Gotta give it a try.

Leave a Comment